Why We Crave the Serial Killer Story: The bodies in Houston’s Bayou Explained
Thirteen bodies have been pulled from Houston’s bayous in recent months. Social media posts and even some news outlets have been quick to declare: “There’s a serial killer on the loose.”
The reality? Probably not.
As a criminologist who studies the intersection of crime and popular culture, I’ve been asked repeatedly about this story. Why do people want to believe a serial killer is responsible when the data points in other directions? The answer isn’t just about criminology. It’s about culture, psychology, and the stories we tell ourselves when faced with tragedy.
The Reality Check
Let’s start with the evidence.
Serial killers are super rare in the United States today. While they are the boogeymen in our collective imagination, the FBI and criminological research show that most homicides (and most body recoveries) are not the work of a serial killer.
Bodies found in waterways are much more commonly linked to:
Accidental drownings
Intoxication and misadventure
Inability of people to navigate and “escape” channelized bayous
Suicide
Isolated incidents of foul play
That doesn’t make the deaths any less tragic, but it does make the “serial killer” explanation highly unlikely. Multiple tragedies do not automatically equal one predator.
Why the Serial Killer Narrative Thrives
If the evidence doesn’t support the theory, then why does the story keep spreading? A few reasons:
Pop culture has made us look for it. Films and streaming series like The Silence of the Lambs and Mindhunter as well as true-crime podcasts and Netflix documentaries illustrate that serial killers dominate our entertainment. When we hear about multiple deaths, our brains immediately reach for the cultural script we know best.
It’s comforting to have a villain. As strange as it sounds, believing in a single “monster” feels less frightening than facing messy realities like mental health crises, addiction, poverty, or inadequate safety infrastructure. One villain is easier to understand (and fight!) than thinking about how to tackle social issues.
The media amplifies it. Let’s be honest: “Possible serial killer in Houston” drives clicks. “Cluster of unconnected tragedies” does not. Once the idea is out there, confirmation bias does the rest. That is, every new body seems to “fit the pattern,” even when the details don’t match.
The Houston Context
Houston’s bayous add a unique backdrop to this myth-making. They’re eerie, cinematic, and already carry an aura of mystery. It’s not surprising that they’ve become the stage for this urban legend.
Every city develops its own folklore: Chicago has its vanishing hitchhiker, Atlanta its stories of missing children, and now Houston may be building its own “bayou killer” myth. This isn’t just about crime. It’s about how communities process fear and uncertainty through storytelling.
My Story: From Clarice Starling to Criminology
This cultural pull toward the serial killer narrative isn’t just something I study. It’s something I’ve lived.
In 1991, as a high school senior (ugh, I know this is going to date me!), I saw The Silence of the Lambs in the movie theater. I walked out of that movie knowing exactly what I was going to do with my life: I was going to be the next Clarice Starling and I was going to hunt serial killers.
Your typical early 1990s senior photo. Yes, that’s me in 1991—a budding Clarice Starling ;)
So I went to Northeastern University to study under James Alan Fox, one of the country’s leading experts on serial homicide. Once there, I learned a hard truth: the Clarice Starling career path doesn’t really exist. Jack McDevitt, the Associate Dean at the time, said to our cohort: “You want to be a criminal profiler? Go to Hollywood.” Serial killers are rare, and most criminologists don’t spend their lives studying them and “tracking them down.”
But something else happened at Northeastern. I met Nicky Rafter, who introduced me to the idea of popular criminology. Popular criminology examines popular culture artifacts that represent crime (film, television, video games, literature, the Internet, etc.) and how these representations impact the public’s perception about crime and criminals. That encounter changed everything.
Now, decades later, here I am—still fascinated by the serial killer myth, but in a different way. Instead of hunting killers, I study why we as a culture are so eager to believe in them.
What This Says About Us
At the core, the “Houston serial killer” story is less about crime statistics and more about cultural psychology.
Humans are natural storytellers; that is, we look for meaning in chaos.
Serial killers provide a neat, cinematic story where randomness feels unbearable.
The myth is a coping mechanism, a way to make sense of tragedy through a villain narrative we recognize.
This is exactly where criminology meets popular culture: when real-world events collide with the stories we’ve been consuming for decades.
Moving Forward
So, is there a serial killer stalking Houston’s bayous? The evidence says no. But the belief in one tells us a lot about how crime stories become cultural stories.
As journalists, social media users, and community members, we need to remember:
Sensational narratives can misdirect attention and resources.
Focusing on myth can distract from real issues like mental health, addiction, or safety.
And while it’s tempting to share a dramatic headline, accuracy matters—especially when lives and communities are at stake.
Final Thoughts
Serial killers may be rare in reality, but they are everywhere in culture. That gap between fact and story is where I work. I explore how crime, horror, and true crime shape the way we see the world.
And if you want to dig deeper into these intersections, that’s exactly what I do as The Pop Culture Criminologist.
👉 Follow me on Instagram and TikTok for more information about crime and pop culture @popculturecriminologist and YouTube at The Pop Culture Criminologist.
👉 Sign up on the mailing list to get exclusive commentary on how criminology intersects with pop culture, horror, and true crime.
👉 Journalists: contact me at Krista@popculturecriminologist.com for media inquiries/appearances.
